The hotel is a decent option for travelers, with a comfortable location right on the water. However, there are some areas that could be improved. The quality of the rooms is average, with some rooms being more updated than others. The pricing is quite competitive, making it a good value for the price. The hotel has made efforts to be innovative with its stay and play packages and water sports activities, but it could benefit from more consistency in its offerings.One of the major drawbacks of this hotel is the inconsistency in the quality of the rooms. Some rooms have been updated with new furniture and amenities, while others still have the old Best Western decor. This can make for a confusing experience for guests who are unsure of what to expect. Additionally, the hotel's policy on pet-friendliness is unclear, with some guests reporting that they were not allowed to bring their pets, while others were not charged for pet fees.On the other hand, the hotel's location is a major selling point. It is situated right on the water, with stunning views of the surrounding area. The hotel's coffee shop, Grassroots, is also a great place to grab a cup of coffee and people-watch. The hotel's staff is friendly and helpful, and they go out of their way to make sure guests have a good experience.Overall, the Paddletail Waterfront Lodge is a decent option for travelers who are looking for a comfortable and convenient place to stay. However, it could benefit from some improvements in the quality of its rooms and consistency of its offerings.Some of the highlights of the hotel include its great location, friendly staff, and stay and play packages. However, there are also some issues that need to be addressed, such as the inconsistency in room quality and the unclear policy on pet-friendliness. With some improvements, this hotel could become a top-rated option for travelers in the area.