The Old Mill Tavern is a rustic, lodge-style restaurant that offers a cozy and lively atmosphere. The venue is perfect for tourists, groups, and families, with a variety of amenities such as a bar onsite, restroom, table service, and seating. The menu features a range of offerings, including wine, small plates, quick bites, late-night food, happy hour food, and happy hour drinks.
The food is a highlight of the experience, with many customers praising the delicious flavors and generous portions. The restaurant is also known for its great beer selection, live performances, and karaoke. However, some customers have mentioned that the service can be slow or unfriendly, which is a notable issue.
One notable incident was a customer's experience with a rude waitress and a poorly handled situation with identification. The customer felt unwelcome and uncomfortable, which is not the kind of experience one would expect from a local hangout. It's essential for the staff to be friendly and accommodating to ensure customers feel welcome and have a great time.
Overall, the Old Mill Tavern is a great spot for those looking for a lively atmosphere and good food. However, the service can be a letdown, and the staff needs to work on being more welcoming and friendly.