Mattison's City Grille is a popular restaurant in downtown Sarasota, known for its varied New American menu, live music, and tiki-inspired outdoor setting. With an overall score of 4.2, the restaurant has received praise for its quality, pricing, and innovativeness, but room for improvement in terms of quality.The restaurant's quality is a mixed bag, with some diners enjoying their meals and others finding them to be just average. The menu offers a wide range of options, but some dishes may be overpriced or not worth the cost. The restaurant's pricing, however, is generally considered to be reasonable, with most meals falling in the $20-$50 range.Mattison's City Grille's innovativeness is one of its strengths, with a lively atmosphere and live music that adds to the dining experience. The restaurant's outdoor setting is also a major draw, with covered seating and a fun vibe that's perfect for a night out.Some of the highlights of Mattison's City Grille include its great wine list, excellent service, and fun atmosphere. Diners have praised the restaurant's attentive staff, who are happy to answer questions and make recommendations. The restaurant's menu is also a major draw, with a wide range of options to suit all tastes and dietary needs.However, some diners have noted that the restaurant can be noisy, especially when live music is playing. The menu may also be a bit too large, with some dishes feeling like they're trying to do too much. Additionally, some diners have reported issues with service, such as long wait times or inattentive servers.Overall, Mattison's City Grille is a solid choice for diners looking for a fun and lively atmosphere, but it may not be the best option for those seeking a more low-key experience. With some tweaks to the menu and service, this restaurant could be an even bigger hit with diners.