business or service...

Tampa Bay

Open Now

Caragiulos Italian American

4.3

• (1 reviews)

69 S Palm Avenue, Sarasota, Florida 34236

45.76

69 S Palm Avenue, Sarasota, Florida 34236

45.76

Directions

Call now

Website

Overview

Fresh-baked breads, meatballs & homemade mozzarella star at this casual, family-run Italian eatery.

Features

Credit cards

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Outdoor seating

Takeout

Dine-in

Great cocktails

Great coffee

Great dessert

Great wine list

Dinner

Solo dining

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

Coffee

Hard liquor

Healthy options

Small plates

Vegetarian options

Wine

Dinner

Dessert

Seating

Bar onsite

Restroom

Cozy

Romantic

Trendy

Upscale

Family-friendly

Groups

Tourists

Dinner reservations recommended

Accepts reservations

High chairs

Parking

Delivery

Lunch

Comfort food

Lunch

Paid parking lot

Paid street parking

Great beer selection

Happy hour drinks

Catering

Kids' menu

Fast service

Casual

Good for kids

Happy hour food

Dogs allowed outside

No-contact delivery

Assistive hearing loop

Serves local specialty

Table service

Reviews

Submit a review

4.3

1 reviews

Quality

3.1

Pricing

5.0

Overall

4.3

Innovativeness

4.5

Submit a review

Synergy AI assistant

Tue, Feb 24, 2026

4.3

Caragiulo's Italian American restaurant is a well-established eatery in downtown Sarasota, offering a range of Italian dishes in a cozy atmosphere. The restaurant's menu includes a variety of pasta, pizza, and other Italian classics, making it a great option for families, couples, and groups of friends. The prices are reasonable, with most meals falling in the $20-$50 range. The restaurant's innovativeness is evident in its commitment to using high-quality ingredients and traditional Italian recipes. However, some guests have reported inconsistent service and quality, which may affect their overall experience. One issue that has been highlighted by some guests is the inconsistency in the quality of food and service. While some guests have reported excellent experiences, others have mentioned receiving incorrect orders or poor service. The restaurant's management has acknowledged these issues and is working to address them. Overall, Caragiulo's is a solid choice for Italian cuisine in Sarasota, but guests should be aware of the potential for inconsistency in service and quality.