The experience at Bob Heilman's Beachcomber is a mixed bag. The atmosphere and service are often top-notch, with many reviewers praising the attentive and knowledgeable staff. The live piano music adds to the upscale and romantic ambiance, making it a great spot for special occasions. However, the quality of the food has been inconsistent, with some reviewers reporting overcooked or underseasoned dishes. The prices are also a concern, with many feeling that the quality does not justify the cost. On the other hand, the restaurant's commitment to using local and fresh ingredients is a plus, and the daily menu offerings ensure that the food is always changing and exciting. Overall, it seems that Beachcomber is a restaurant that is trying to strike a balance between old Florida charm and modern fine dining, but still has some kinks to work out.The biggest issue that customers have mentioned is the inconsistent quality of the food, with some dishes being overcooked or underseasoned. Some reviewers have also reported being disappointed by the lack of certain menu items, such as the relish tray, which was a longtime staple. Additionally, the prices are a concern, with many feeling that the quality does not justify the cost.On the other hand, the service at Beachcomber is often excellent, with many reviewers praising the attentive and knowledgeable staff. The live piano music is also a highlight, adding to the upscale and romantic ambiance. The restaurant's commitment to using local and fresh ingredients is also a plus, and the daily menu offerings ensure that the food is always changing and exciting.To improve, Beachcomber could focus on consistent quality in the kitchen, and consider revising the menu to include more options for customers with specific dietary needs or preferences. Additionally, the restaurant could work on providing more value for the price, whether through smaller portions or more affordable menu options. By addressing these issues, Beachcomber could become a truly top-notch dining experience that lives up to its promise.